Churches in Shelter Island, New York

2 churches in Shelter Island, NY, from public records and OpenStreetMap. Open a church to see its address, denomination and nearby congregations, or join it on GodsGoodBook to read the Bible along with its members.

  1. Saint Marys Episcopal Church

    26 Saint Marys Road, 11964

    Episcopal

  2. Shelter Island Presbyterian Church

    32 North Ferry Road, 11964

    Presbyterian (other)

More churches in New York

Is your church missing or listed wrongly?

Search the directory, or add your church and its leaders can claim it.

Search New York churches

Directory data from HIFLD and © OpenStreetMap contributors.

GodsGoodBook logo

GodsGoodBook

Making God's Word accessible to everyone

Experience the Bible like never before with multiple translations, powerful search tools, and features to make God's Word personal to you. Completely free, forever.

© 2026 GodsGoodBookVersion 2.1.1